I learnt something the hard way this week.
Once you start baking with Nutella, you can't stop.
This time around was nutella cookies.
I don't think I have to tell you how fantastic they were.
Were. As in past tense.
::shame::
Just the words nutella and cookie should be an easy sell.
Plus, as husband mentioned, nutella is good for you. (Marketing works, even if it is directed toward kids).
Doesn't matter to me, I'll do whatever husband says.
I love the way that man thinks.
Peanut Butter & Nutella Swirl Cookies
Adapted from: Sweetest Kitchen
Ingredients
1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
3/4 cup smooth peanut butter
1/2 cup white sugar
1/2 cup packed brown sugar
1 egg
1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
3/4 teaspoon baking soda
1/4 teaspoon salt
1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
Approx. 1/4 cup Nutella
Directions
Preheat oven to 350° F.
Combine butter, peanut butter, sugars, egg, and vanilla. Mix until well blended.
Add flour, baking soda and salt. Drizzle Nutella on top of the dough then swirl it through the dough with a butter knife.
Chill dough 15 minutes in the refrigerator. Roll into balls by hand. Place on parchment lined cookie sheet. Using a fork, press down the balls to flatten slightly. Bake until edges are very lightly browned (about 7 to 10 minutes).
Allow to rest 2 minutes on cookie sheet before transferring cookies to a cooling rack.
PS - Huge thanks to The Doctor's Closet for the delicious post and mention of our Peanut Butter Nutella Cookie Cups!
I am a total Nutella addict- but I have never cooked with it beyond spreading it on crepes (does that count?) These looks so yum!
ReplyDeleteI have never tried nutella cookies - looks like they are patiently waiting to be devoured!
ReplyDeleteOooh - and I just bought a huge 2-pack of nutella at Costco! Yay!
ReplyDeleteI cannot wait to try these Mary, I will let you know how many I end up eating in one sesh!
ReplyDeleteReally, really have to try these! Mhhh...
ReplyDeletewhaaaaa - MAKING these tonight - i have all the ingrediants too - THANKS LOVE!!!!
ReplyDeleteI know what you mean! Though I think it's safer for me to bake with it than to have the jar in my kitchen...just asking to be opened at any and all times day or night!
ReplyDeleteOh these look so delicious.....two of my fav ingredients - PB and nutella! This looks like a great one...thank you so much for posting this!!
ReplyDeleteoh yum! that marbled coloring looks fabulous and they look oh so chewy n good. Buttercreambarbie
ReplyDeleteI am picking up some Nutella today (it never stays long at my house) so I can make these cookies tonight!!
ReplyDeletetempting cookies, feel like giving a big bite.
ReplyDeleteYou had me on the nutella. Surely is delicious.
ReplyDeleteWhat a delicious twist on peanut butter cookies.
ReplyDeleteThanks for visiting my blog, so I could find yours! :)
Thanks for the comment Mary.
ReplyDeleteYour cookies look amazing, I'm a huge fan of peanut butter and nutella, I need to attempt these... very nice site and great photography. :-)
Happy I found you too. You have a great blog here!
ReplyDeleteThose cookies look fabulous!
Nutella is like a drug. I don't mind being a slave to her at all, tho. :-p She's lovely, isn't she? These cookies look outstanding. I love how rustic they look, and the PB combo with the Nutella sounds intoxicating! :-p Love it!
ReplyDeletemmmmmmm :) good.
ReplyDeleteYummy cookies, I love the combination of peanut butter and nutella.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the visit, glad you found me so I could fine you, those cookies look fantastic. I'd love some!
ReplyDeleteOMG love these! So glad you stopped by my site so i could find yours!
ReplyDeleteMary - Thanks so much for dropping by my blog the other day and for your lovely comment! I'm glad to have found your blog as well - it's beautiful. I love your clean layout and bright, crisp photos.
ReplyDeleteI'm also not a peanut butter fan, but I think mixed with some nutella might convert me. :)
Have a great week!
Ooooo, those look seriously yummy! I've never been able to keep Nutella in the house. :) Gotta say though, if you ever try the Rapunzel brand of chocolate hazelnut spread, wow, it is sublime. Nutella to the next dimension. I could eat an entire jar of that in one sitting. Hello truffle filling! Thanks for stopping by, I think I may have to try these once I'm back on carbs. ♥
ReplyDeleteso I was just sitting here thinking about dessert and then I see this post! YUMMM
ReplyDeletethank you for the constant inspiration :)
pepperandchips.blogspot.com
I have a thing for Nutella and these cookies look over top good! I'm glad I found you too!!
ReplyDeleteWow.. this looks so rich and nice. And yes, I love nutella too. Definitely will bookmark this in my to-bake-list !
ReplyDeletethose look AWESOME! i'll have to give them a go sometime.
ReplyDeletexoxo,
http://www.lovintheoven.com
wow, are you on a nutella roll or what! ;) looks like it's getting better and better! mary, i can't wait for the next recipe :D
ReplyDeleteThese cookies look majorly delicious, love the swirl! I've been out of nutella for far too long, I need to get some and try these cookies!
ReplyDeleteYes yes and yes! You had me at nutella. Will have to make these asap.
ReplyDeleteOh, those are so pretty. I always see Giada baking with Nutella but I am not a huge hazelnut fan, so I didn't think I would like Nutella, but you have just convinced me to give it a try!
ReplyDeleteOh my... I have honestly never baked (or at least not since I have lived on my own, which has been... 11 years. So uh. Pretty much never! But these make me want to tryyyy! I love nutella (I highly suggest grilled nutella sandwiches in a panini press!) and pb cookies are my fave, so this sounds like a dream!
ReplyDeleteOkay so you are the one who's about to add 20 pounds to my a* I mean hips! These look crazy good. I have to say I'm a little pissed Dominos does not deliver these. ahahaha!
ReplyDeleteThank you for stopping by my page, I really appreciate you taking the time to comment.
These would not last long in my house
ReplyDeleteYou had me at Nutella ;) I think I know what I am making this weekend! Thanks for stopping by, and the kind comment!
ReplyDeleteI just wanted to say thank u for stopping by my blog and for u'r kind words ... I love u'r blog too ... i've been looking for some muffin recipes and the ones on u'r blog seem lovely ... I'll be back for more ;)
ReplyDeleteWow - those cookies look lethally delicious! I may have to brave baking with Nutella to try them.
ReplyDeleteI don't buy nutella because I would just eat the whole jar with a spoon! These cookies look delish, maybe I will succumb!
ReplyDeleteI am defiantly making these, YUM!! They look so pretty!!
ReplyDeleteI'm bookmarking these and making them this weekend. Yummy!
ReplyDeleteCan I also say that I appreciate your beautiful food photography. So lovely.
These look great!! I can't wait to make them. And I Must say, your blog is very eye catching. The photos are amazing!
ReplyDeleteThanks for leaving a comment on my blog. I'm glad you found me, because now I've found you! I was just checking out all of your cookies posts, and cakes, and treats - lol.... Can you tell I'm a sweet tooth junkie? These cookies are beautiful. Thanks for sharing your recipe!
ReplyDeleteThanks for visiting my blog today. Your site is great I'm glad I stopped and I'll be back for more great recipes.
ReplyDeleteNutella rocks my world! I eat it by the spoonful.
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by my blog..it brought me to your BEAUTIFUL site!
Looks like we've got two nutella spooning men on our hands! I just had to make a nutella tart as a peace offering for mine! Cookies, look great. I'll have to bookmark this for the next time I get myself in trouble!
ReplyDeleteNutella in cookies? So genius and obvious yet I'd never thought of it/had it!
ReplyDeleteNew use for my Nutella jar other then eating it by the spoonful ;)
are you serious?!?!?! these look incredible! on my must try list!
ReplyDeleteTwo of my favorite foods, nutella and peanut butter, both in the same cookie?! Yum! I cannot wait to try this recipe!
ReplyDeleteWow, these look amazing! So much more interesting than plain peanut butter cookies!
ReplyDeleteI have a love affair with Nutella. But.... ssshhh... don't tell anyone. I eat it by the spoonfuls when no one is watching. These look amazing!
ReplyDeleteHey girl! Thanks for stopping by the Food Hound! I love your blog, too! And I am totally loving these cookies-- Nutella and peanut butter cookies must be what they serve in heaven, right?? I am almost out of Nutella so I guess I have to buy more OR try to make my own-- it would be dangerous, indeed, if I could make it at a moment's notice :)
ReplyDeleteThose cookies look ridiculously good. Seriously. Love the blog, can relate on many levels. (Dysfunctional dieter...so perfect) Great pix too.
ReplyDeleteJust found your blog via cupcakesandcashmere and I cannot wait to make your recipes! What a wonderful blog.
ReplyDeleteStellar combination! I think these are going to make an appearance in my kitchen really soon!
ReplyDeleteJust found your blog the other day (from your comment in my blog...thanks :)....love it...so many great recipes!
Mary, looked for your email and can't find it. I used your recipe and linked back to you on my blog. If this isn't ok please email me brusedsatin@gmail.com and I will remove it immediately. Amazing recipe.
ReplyDeleteYour blog is beautiful and these cookies look AMAZING. Wow. I am not much of a baker but these make me want to try! Anything involving Nutella must be worth it.
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure which my husband likes more: peanut butter or Nutella. Needless to say, he would go gaga for these!
ReplyDeleteWOW. These are crazy good! Thank you so much for the recipe I LOVE THEM!!!
ReplyDeletemade these for the first time today - and added crushed up pretzels! they're in the oven now and I'm so excited!! :)
ReplyDeleteThank you sooooooo much for this recipe! I just made these with my son and they are to die for!
ReplyDeleteIf you're in need of the metric measurements, I converted and tested this recipe.
ReplyDelete115 g (1 stick) butter
190 g peanut butter
100 g sugar
90 g brown sugar
1 egg
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
3/4 tsp baking soda
1/4 tsp salt
190 g flour
150 g Nutella
Enjoy - these scored major points with my wife!
Packet of brown sugar? Like a tiny one?
ReplyDeleteLooking forward to making these this weekend for a cookie exchange. About how many dozen cookies does this make?
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to try them! Thanks!
Had peanut butter with nutella and banna on bread but never a cookie will make some this week end
ReplyDeleteDo you know how many cookies this makes?
ReplyDelete@Anonymous: It depends on the size but roughly a couple dozen. Enjoy!
ReplyDeletepretty sure I need these in my life =)
ReplyDeleteAre these cookies soft? Look delicious! Want to try them : )
ReplyDelete@Anonymous: Yes, they are! As always, if you prefer softer cookies (I do, too), minus a few minutes off of the cook time! Enjoy!
ReplyDeleteI just made these and they are amazing! definitely making them again!
ReplyDeleteMy dough came out very crumbly and not easy to roll into balls...anyone have any idea why? Thanks
ReplyDeleteMine did too. Maybe too much flour? They wern't as gooey and soft as I thought they would be. More crumbly and dense.
ReplyDeleteThanks for posting this, I'm going to be sharing it on my blog in a Round-Up of Nutella Recipes, I hope you don't mind. You can check it out here if you like.
ReplyDeletehttp://virukka.wordpress.com/2012/01/24/how-many-things-can-you-make-with-nutella/
I just posted your picture with a link back to your site :)
Wondering why the dough was crumbly? I was not able to swirl the Nutella with a butter knife at all. Hoping they will still taste yummy! :)
ReplyDeletePeanut butter cookie doughs do tend to be rather crumbly. Don't try to roll the dough out and spread nutella on top like a pinwheel cookie.. too crumbly for that!
ReplyDeleteCan you do it with out the brown sugar or substitute it with white sugar, that's the only ingredient I don't have in the kitchen lol
ReplyDeleteThose look SO yummy! I featured them today on my “Top 10 Nutella Recipes” post. Feel free to grab a “featured” button. Also I would love for you to share this (and any other creations) at my new linky party “Pin It and Win It Wednesday” @www.cheapcraftymama.com!
ReplyDeletenutella is not good for you!!! it has 2.5 g of saturated fat per serving! eakkk! marketing works..but not always in a good way.
ReplyDeleteCan these be frozen?
ReplyDeleteCan these be frozen?
ReplyDeleteHow many cookies does this recipe make?
ReplyDeleteOh my, I just made these and they are amazing! Like melt in your mouth good. Dangerous though...I just ate 4 in one sitting!
ReplyDeleteVery easy to make I kneaded the nutella into the dough bc cant swirl, it mixed just a tad more so they are not as pretty. I used baking powder instead of baking soda and crunchy Pb vs smooth. They are good but cant taste nutella like I expected
ReplyDeleteMy cookies were very crunchy despite my attempts at shorter bake times. Any ideas? Thanks for the recipe...they were very tasty.
ReplyDeletePeanut Butter Nutella Swirl Cookies are delectable treats combining creamy peanut butter and rich Nutella in a delightful cookie dough. The resulting swirl pattern creates a visually appealing and flavorful fusion. Best 5 Games These cookies offer a perfect balance of nutty, chocolatey goodness, making them a favorite among cookie enthusiasts.
ReplyDelete